(714) 766-1669
HOA Boards3 min read2026-11-04

Fines vs. Towing: Choosing the Right HOA Enforcement Tool

Quick answer

Towing solves the immediate problem and follows the Vehicle Code; fines address repeat behavior and require notice and a hearing under the Davis-Stirling Act. Most associations use both.

Fines and towing do different jobs.

Towing

  • Clears the space now
  • Governed by CVC §22658: signs, authorization, presence
  • Paid by the vehicle owner, whoever that is
  • Best for fire lanes, blocked access, guest parking abuse, and non-residents

Fines

  • Address repeat behavior by an owner
  • Governed by the Davis-Stirling Act: the board needs a schedule of monetary penalties distributed to members (Civil Code §5850) and has to give the member notice and an opportunity for a hearing before imposing one (Civil Code §5855)
  • Paid by the owner, even if their tenant or guest caused the violation, depending on your documents

When to Use Which

  • Safety violations: tow.
  • Non-residents in resident or guest spaces: tow.
  • Residents who repeatedly break garage or guest rules: warn, then fine, and tow when the vehicle is in violation of posted rules.
  • Oversized vehicles: warn, then tow or fine depending on your rules.

Consistency

Whichever you use, apply it the same way to everyone.

Have your association's attorney review your fine schedule and hearing process.

A Sample Escalation for Repeat Residents

  1. Written reminder of the rule
  2. Notice of violation and hearing
  3. Fine under the penalty schedule
  4. Towing when the vehicle is parked against posted rules in common areas

Write the steps into your enforcement policy so residents know what to expect.

Related: notice and hearing before HOA parking fines.

On an HOA board or managing one in Orange County or Los Angeles?

We install free tow-away signs and paint curbs with a towing agreement, train the people your board authorizes, and send tow reports for board meetings. Send the short form and we'll set up a free property walk.

Request a free property walk

Takes about a minute. We'll email or call you back.

Free tow-away signs and curb painting with a towing agreement

We only use your details to reply about your property. Privacy

Or email info@kotowingandrecovery.com