Quick answer
Towing solves the immediate problem and follows the Vehicle Code; fines address repeat behavior and require notice and a hearing under the Davis-Stirling Act. Most associations use both.
Fines and towing do different jobs.
Towing
- Clears the space now
- Governed by CVC §22658: signs, authorization, presence
- Paid by the vehicle owner, whoever that is
- Best for fire lanes, blocked access, guest parking abuse, and non-residents
Fines
- Address repeat behavior by an owner
- Governed by the Davis-Stirling Act: the board needs a schedule of monetary penalties distributed to members (Civil Code §5850) and has to give the member notice and an opportunity for a hearing before imposing one (Civil Code §5855)
- Paid by the owner, even if their tenant or guest caused the violation, depending on your documents
When to Use Which
- Safety violations: tow.
- Non-residents in resident or guest spaces: tow.
- Residents who repeatedly break garage or guest rules: warn, then fine, and tow when the vehicle is in violation of posted rules.
- Oversized vehicles: warn, then tow or fine depending on your rules.
Consistency
Whichever you use, apply it the same way to everyone.
Have your association's attorney review your fine schedule and hearing process.
A Sample Escalation for Repeat Residents
- Written reminder of the rule
- Notice of violation and hearing
- Fine under the penalty schedule
- Towing when the vehicle is parked against posted rules in common areas
Write the steps into your enforcement policy so residents know what to expect.
Related: notice and hearing before HOA parking fines.
On an HOA board or managing one in Orange County or Los Angeles?
We install free tow-away signs and paint curbs with a towing agreement, train the people your board authorizes, and send tow reports for board meetings. Send the short form and we'll set up a free property walk.