Quick answer
Small claims cases usually turn on the signs, the authorization, and photos of the violation. Gather those records, send someone who knows the facts, and work with the tow company.
Small claims court is where most tow disputes that go to court end up.
What the Court Looks At
- Were compliant signs posted at the entrance?
- Was the tow authorized in writing by someone the association authorized?
- Was that person present?
- Was the vehicle actually in violation?
- Were the charges within what the law allows?
Records to Gather
- Photos of the signs at the entrance
- The signed authorization
- Photos of the violation (we photograph the violation before every tow)
- Patrol and tow reports
- The parking rules and proof they were distributed
Who Goes
Associations can send an authorized representative. The manager or patrol supervisor who knows the facts is often best.
Work With the Tow Company
The tow company may also be named.
Settle When It's Right
If the tow was a mistake, it's often better to make it right before court.
Preparing for the Hearing
- Organize the records in order: rules, notice to members, signs, authorization, photos, reports.
- Bring copies for the judge and the other party.
- Be ready to explain the rule in one or two sentences.
- Stay factual and polite.
Judges see these cases often. Clear records and a calm explanation make a difference.
Related: handling homeowner complaints about towing.
On an HOA board or managing one in Orange County or Los Angeles?
We install free tow-away signs and paint curbs with a towing agreement, train the people your board authorizes, and send tow reports for board meetings. Send the short form and we'll set up a free property walk.